Wednesday, January 15, 2014

Visiting Millikin Basics and Laurelwood

Millikin is one of the best elementary schools in States. It is a public school in Santa Clara county. But due to the high enrollment, it is run by lottery. The chance of winning a lottery is 1:4.

We had a visit during the open house on Tuesday. We dropped in a few classes and attended the meeting hosted by the principle. In general it is a great school with high disciplines. All kids are seated well, behaving well in the classroom, and participating discussions in the class. I like the message they are passing that kids' job is going to school and study. They have strict dress code to avoid the distractions. They are very strict about what to teach too. Teachers only teach the requirements at the grade level. Even if the whole class are advanced and ready for the next level, the teacher will still stick to the curriculum. This may make some students feel bored.


While glancing the homework hung on the wall, I spotted a few spelling errors. I am a little disappointed by that. It seems that the teacher doesn't go through the homework and do any corrections at all. Though I didn't think the education system in China is great, I remember clearly how hard our teachers graded our homework. Sometime it made kids feel shame on it. Such a big difference.


I asked my friends about the public schools in Cupertino. It seems that the elementary schools are not as good as boasted. The teacher doesn't grade students' homework much. Most of the parents send their kids to after schools where they learn the discipline and learn something really serious. I haven't visited them. One may visit and correct this.


I just dropped by Laurelwood elementary for some basic information. The staff there is very helpful and com potent. She explained to us the rule for registration. According to the federal law, the minimum age for admittance to kindergarten in California in public schools is five by September 1. Private schools don't have these requirements. At Laurelwood the teacher will observe the kids behavior for two months or so in the kindergarten. If the kid is ready for the first grade, they will move them from kindergarten to the first grade. The staff also explains to us the differences between Washiongton Open, Milikin, and public schools like Laurelwood. At Washington Open, parents need to involves a lot both in classroom and after schools. For Milikin, only teachers teach. It doesn't allow parents to teach anything in classroom or at home. It doesn't let students do group projects either. At Laurelwood, there are some parents involvements, but not as much as in Washington Open. It also allows students to do group projects and teach each other.


After observations in these schools, I started to like montessori method more and Marva Collins' book. One may buy the book at amazon: Marva Collins' Way.

To deeply understand the public schools, the flat world and education is a good reference.

5 comments:

  1. Great article! Thanks for sharing.

    I feel the teachers in the states have heavier workload than their counterparts in China. I remember my elementary Chinese teachers only needed to teach one class every day, of course it was a big class of 50 plus students, but the teaching time was only 40 minutes. So they had much more time to do the grading. The Chinese teachers do face more pressure in terms of testing, though.

    ReplyDelete
  2. As a teacher, many do not grade homework as it is supposed to reinforce a lesson and let kids practice a skill and self correct. It should never be part of a child's academic grade, as some students receive a great deal of help with their homework (private tutors, etc.) while others receive none. Research supports that homework does not help improve academic performance. Check out Finland and their philosophies on teaching and homework. They are the highest performing country with their schools.

    ReplyDelete
  3. As a teacher, many do not grade homework as it is supposed to reinforce a lesson and let kids practice a skill and self correct. It should never be part of a child's academic grade, as some students receive a great deal of help with their homework (private tutors, etc.) while others receive none. Research supports that homework does not help improve academic performance. Check out Finland and their philosophies on teaching and homework. They are the highest performing country with their schools.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Which school did you end up enrolling in?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I feel not so much difference between public schools.

      Delete